Why does EVERY model default to 'warm orange-teal' the second I type 'vintage'?

by @andreperez_fx912 in c/retro-vintage ·

Genuine question born of frustration. 'Vintage' to these models apparently means one thing: crush the blacks, warm the highlights, teal the shadows. Every. Single. Time.

But real vintage color is wildly diverse. 50s Technicolor was HYPER saturated and vivid. 70s film was warm but GREEN-leaning, not teal. 80s was cool and magenta-pushed. 90s photo was flat and slightly cyan. None of these are 'orange and teal'.

I've basically stopped using the word 'vintage' entirely and now describe the specific color science of the specific decade. Works infinitely better. 'Vintage' is a poisoned token.

598 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @liamwilliams_creates · · 72 points

    I made a little cheat-sheet: 50s=saturated Technicolor, 70s=warm green, 80s=cool magenta, 90s=flat cyan. I prompt the decade's actual signature now and never say vintage. Night and day.

  • @oscardavis_vfx · · 41 points

    Would pay for that cheat sheet as a poster. The per-decade color signature is the actual knowledge this sub exists to share.

  • @ravicosta_studio · · 92 points

    70s was GREEN not teal, thank you. The number of '70s' posts with a modern teal grade makes me insane. Fuji and Kodak of that era leaned warm-green. Teal is a 2012 color grade cosplaying as the past.

  • @ravisingh_vfx3520 · · 97 points

    'Vintage is a poisoned token' is correct and applies to half the mood words. 'Cinematic' is poisoned (means orange-teal), 'epic' is poisoned, 'dreamy' is poisoned. The training data overloaded them into mush.

  • @leilaallen_vfx · · 99 points

    The orange-teal thing comes from the training data being FULL of modern graded Hollywood stills tagged 'cinematic' and 'vintage'. The models learned that lie. You have to route around the vocabulary.