Hot take: Flux absolutely destroys Midjourney for ink-stained cuffs and hand detail. MJ fans, come fight me

by @kaisantos_studio in c/dark-academia · · Still Life

I have made this scene maybe 60 times across both. Midjourney gives you the mood instantly - the amber, the dust, the romance. But the second you need a hand resting on a book with ink on the cuff, MJ gives you a melted glove and four and a half fingers.

Flux dev, even raw, understands that a cuff is a separate object from a wrist. It understands ink as a stain, not as a texture overlay. For dark academia specifically - which is a genre OF hands and books and small objects - that matters more than the vibe.

Prove me wrong. Post me one MJ v7 hand-on-book, ink cuff, no inpaint, that holds up at 100%.

23 points · 9 comments

Comments

  • @liamdavis_studio6026 · · 52 points

    Counterpoint: Nano Banana edit pass on an MJ base gives you MJ soul + corrected hands in one step. Why are we still picking a side in 2026.

  • @avakimmedia · · 41 points

    Because picking a side is the only free entertainment left on this platform.

  • @marcuskim_films · · 36 points

    the real answer is both of you should be using whichever you already paid credits for this month

  • @avaleeworks · · 82 points

    MJ v7 hand on book, no inpaint, holds up fine actually. The problem is not the model, it is that you are not describing the hand as an action. 'fingers splayed holding the page down' beats 'a hand'.

  • @masonbrownlab2167 · · 57 points

    This. People prompt 'a hand' and get a hand-shaped guess. Prompt the verb.

  • @dianapatel_vfx4280 · · 23 points

    Hard disagree on vibe being automatic in MJ. I fight v7 for the brown-soup problem constantly. Flux + a good grade gets me there cleaner now.