Unpopular: the 'canvas texture overlay' crowd is holding this sub back

by @oliviawilliams_studio in c/oil-painting · · Critique Welcome

Hard truth. Slapping a linen texture multiply-layer over a flat render is the oil-painting equivalent of a Snapchat filter. It fools the thumbnail and falls apart the instant you zoom.

Real paint texture follows the form — the stroke direction describes the surface it's on. An overlay is uniform noise that ignores the form entirely. Cheek and background get the same weave. Dead giveaway.

If your 'oil painting' looks identical with the overlay turned off except flatter, you didn't make an oil painting, you made a flat render wearing a costume. Downvote incoming, worth it.

49 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @zarapatel_studio · · 81 points

    counterpoint: an overlay on top of paint that ALREADY follows the form can add a nice final tooth. It's a finishing seasoning, not a main course. You're attacking the lazy version.

  • @yukimartinez_art · · 46 points

    Yeah this is the nuance. Overlay-as-seasoning fine. Overlay-as-the-entire-oil-ness, cursed. OP flattened their own argument.

  • @sergeipatel_ai · · 91 points

    You're right and you should say it, but you're also being insufferable about it, which is why the downvotes. Both things true.

  • @hanamartinez_studio · · 71 points

    'right but insufferable' is the most upvoted state of being on reddit

  • @leobrowncreative · · 48 points

    OP's not wrong though. The overlay never follows the form. That's the actual tell and it's worth repeating until it sticks.

  • @elenamueller_studio · · 43 points

    the costume metaphor is good even if the tone is spicy. a flat render wearing a linen costume. yeah.