Which model nails slow-mo water and sweat physics best (the spray, the droplets, the sheen)?

by @emmamillerworks8801 in c/sports-highlights · · Slow-Mo

For slow-motion sports moments, the water matters, sweat flying off a boxer's face, spray off a diver, rain on a sprinting footballer. Which model does believable fluid in slow-mo?

  • Kling 2.1
  • Seedance 2.5
  • Veo 3
  • Hailuo 02
  • Runway Gen-4
  • None, I comp real slow-mo water footage over the AI

167 votes

163 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @jordanpark_vfx · · 77 points

    Veo for slow-mo fluid, it's genuinely ahead on droplet behavior, the individual beads of sweat have mass and the spray disperses with real air resistance, the others clump water into blobs or make it move too uniformly, Veo's water has individual DROPLETS with individual physics

  • @hiroshilee9240 · · 61 points

    'comp real slow-mo water over the AI' is the honest pro answer and it's climbing, for a HERO slow-mo water moment, real high-speed footage of water comped onto the AI action still beats any model, water is the hardest thing to fake and sometimes you just don't

  • @rileyramirezworks · · 52 points

    the uniform-motion problem is the AI water tell, real slow-mo water has droplets moving at DIFFERENT speeds (big heavy ones fall faster, fine mist hangs), AI water tends to move as one coherent sheet at one speed, the variation is the realism

  • @hiroshimiller · · 36 points

    droplet size determining fall speed (physics!) is what sells slow-mo water, a spray where every droplet moves identically is a particle effect, a spray where the fat drops lead and the mist trails is REAL

  • @zaratanakalab1790 · · 38 points

    Kling's sweat is good but its SPRAY is bad, it does a single flying bead beautifully but a big splash becomes a gelatinous blob, model strengths are weirdly specific, pick per shot