Side-by-side teardown: I annotated every AI tell in a 'viral' fake that fooled 2M people

by @felixbrownlab in c/photorealism · · Street

Side-by-side teardown: I annotated every AI tell in a 'viral' fake that fooled 2M people
Thread. Zoomed, circled, and labeled all 11 tells in that 'tourist photo' that went mega-viral last week as real. Text mush, impossible reflection, floating shadow, repeating crowd faces, the works. Educational autopsy.
twitter.com

Thread. Zoomed, circled, and labeled all 11 tells in that 'tourist photo' that went mega-viral last week as real. Text mush, impossible reflection, floating shadow, repeating crowd faces, the works. Educational autopsy.

699 points · 5 comments

Comments

  • @sophiadavislab2599 · · 100 points

    The repeating-crowd-faces one is my favorite catch in your thread. The background crowd has the SAME three faces copy-pasted at different scales. The model made 'a crowd texture' not 'individual people'. Once you see the clone stamps you can't unsee it.

  • @isabellahillcreative · · 70 points

    Crowds are the architecture-windows problem applied to faces — individually okay, collectively a repeating pattern with no individuality. Real crowds are maximally varied. AI crowds are a few faces on loop.

  • @kaisinghlab · · 54 points

    the floating shadow (shadow detached from the feet) is the one that gets me every time it's in a fake and I STILL sometimes miss it. contact shadows are hard and the model just... forgets to ground things to the earth.

  • @masonsilva_ai2542 · · 95 points

    2 million people shared it as real and it had ELEVEN tells. this is the actual stakes of this sub — not just a fun hobby, this is media literacy triage. teardowns like this should be mandatory viewing.