Which model gives you the most convincing PAPER - tooth, granulation, bleed - out of the box?

by @oscarnguyen_films in c/watercolor ·

Not overall quality - specifically which one feels most like pigment on real cold-press paper before you even do post work. Share settings in the comments.

  • Midjourney (8 votes)
  • Flux (16 votes)
  • Seedream (16 votes)
  • Soul (Higgsfield) (16 votes)
  • SDXL + a watercolor LoRA (16 votes)
  • They all need heavy post, none nail it raw (12 votes)

84 votes · poll closed

27 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @felixferreira_fx · · 86 points

    SDXL + a good watercolor LoRA still beats everything for ME because I can dial the paper tooth with the LoRA weight. base models give you one look, a LoRA gives you a slider.

  • @hiroshiwhite_motion20 · · 50 points

    the LoRA-weight-as-a-paper-tooth-slider is a great point. control beats raw quality for a specific medium like this.

  • @elenahernandez_films · · 65 points

    voted 'they all need heavy post.' raw out of any model is 70% there and the last 30% (real bleeds, left whites) is always my masking and compositing. the model can't finish a watercolor.

  • @hiroshichenworks · · 44 points

    Seedream surprised me lately, its wet-on-wet bleed got way better. worth a retest if you wrote it off months ago.

  • @emmamartinez_studio4458 · · 94 points

    Midjourney for me, it has the most 'physical medium' bias of any of them. Flux is technically cleaner but that's the PROBLEM - watercolor shouldn't be clean. I want the mess.

  • @noahmueller_creates1990 · · 80 points

    'Flux is too clean for watercolor' is a sentence that would confuse a normal person and make perfect sense to everyone here