Unpopular opinion: river realism is the least important part of a map and the river police need a hobby

by @zaramartinez_art in c/worldbuilding · · Map / Cartography

I'm going to catch hands for this but: nobody who reads your story cares whether a tributary technically flows uphill. Readers care about the swamp feeling dangerous and the trade route feeling plausible. We have collectively decided that hydrology is the one hard-science hill to die on and I think it's because it's the easiest to check, not the most important.

Meanwhile people post maps with a single mountain range running straight down the middle like a spine, cities with no reason to exist, and empires that span a continent with medieval logistics, and the top comment is 'nice rivers.' Priorities are cooked.

37 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @felixsantos_vfx · · 68 points

    You're half right and picked the most inflammatory possible way to say it. 'Logistics and city-placement are under-critiqued' — true! 'So ignore hydrology' — no. Do both, it's not a budget.

  • @lucasschulz_digital887 · · 56 points

    The real villain is 'spine mountain range down the center of the continent' and I will die on THAT hill with you. It's on every beginner map and it's geologically insane.

  • @sakuraking_studio · · 43 points

    Finally someone says it. Continents aren't fish. Your range needs a plate boundary, not a dorsal fin.

  • @yukilopezworks · · 89 points

    Hard disagree. River errors are a SYMPTOM. If you got the water wrong you probably got the elevation wrong, which means your mountains, rain shadows, and city placement are all vibes. Rivers are just the visible tip.

  • @ravimuellercreative · · 93 points

    This is the actual rebuttal. Nobody cares about rivers for their own sake, we care because wrong rivers reveal you didn't think about terrain AT ALL.

  • @sergeigupta_vfx · · 12 points

    Downvoting because you're correct about priorities and wrong about rivers and I can't upvote a half-truth. Take my spite.