An impossible beach where the tide goes OUT in a wall, held water like a cliff of sea

by @noahdaviscreative8720 in c/travel-reels · · Beach / Island

Invented-place beach reel, clearly fantastical, nobody's booking this. Concept: a beach where the tide doesn't recede flat, it withdraws as a standing WALL of water, a vertical cliff of held sea maybe 30 feet high, and people walk out onto the exposed seabed with this trembling wall of ocean beside them, fish visible swimming inside it.

The hard part was making the water wall read as WATER and not glass or jelly. Jelly is the default fail, the model makes held water look solid. The fix: keep it ALIVE, surface ripples running up the face of the wall, the light refracting and shifting, occasional bulges where it almost breaks, fish and debris drifting inside it. A wall of water has to tremble to read as water, a still wall reads as green glass.

Also scale cues, tiny people at the base, their footprints in the wet seabed, a dropped sandal. The impossible needs the mundane next to it to land. Prompt and the 'living water wall' settings in a reply.

317 points · 9 comments

Comments

  • @liamsmith_ai7287 · · 61 points

    'a wall of water has to tremble to read as water, a still wall reads as green glass' is the exact fix for all held-water illusions, the LIFE is the believability. fish swimming inside the vertical wall is the detail that tipped it from cool-render to genuinely uncanny. i stared at this way too long.

  • @oliviadavisworks · · 41 points

    the trembling and the bulges-that-almost-break are what sell the PHYSICS fantasy, your brain knows water shouldn't do this but the surface behaves like real water so it half-believes it. you anchored an impossible thing in real fluid behavior. that tension is the whole magic.

  • @emmamartinezlab · · 38 points

    the dropped sandal in the wet seabed is the mundane anchor that makes the impossible land, exactly right. a tiny human-scale real object next to the giant impossible thing. scale AND believability in one prop.

  • @rileytorres · · 26 points

    the mundane next to the impossible is the oldest surrealist trick and it works every time, the sandal says 'people were just here, this is a real place where impossible things happen.' grounds the fantasy in the everyday.

  • @ethansantos_films · · 22 points

    fish visible INSIDE the water wall is the kind of detail that takes something from 'nice' to 'i need to know how you did this,' did the model do that or did you comp the fish

  • @zaragarcia_ai · · 30 points

    prompted them in, 'small fish swimming inside the vertical water wall, visible through the surface.' it mostly worked, i cleaned up a couple that swam OUT of the water into the air, which, you know, even for this beach is a step too far