Hot take: slow-mo is a crutch and most of you use it to hide that the actual motion is bad

by @kaikim_films in c/sports-highlights · · Slow-Mo

Come at me. Slow-motion has become the AI sports crutch, and I think a LOT of people reach for it not because the moment deserves it but because their real-time motion looks WRONG and slowing it down hides the jank. At 0.1x speed, you can't tell the running cycle is broken or the ball path is off, everything looks 'epic' in slow-mo.

Real-time motion is the actual test. Can your player RUN convincingly at full speed? Can the ball move at real velocity and still look right? That's hard, and slow-mo lets you dodge it entirely. I've started making myself nail the real-time version FIRST, and only then adding a slow-mo accent, and my work got dramatically better because I stopped hiding behind the slug-speed.

Slow-mo should be a SPICE, a moment of emphasis on motion that already works. When the WHOLE clip is slow-mo, that's not style, that's camouflage. Fight me (in slow motion, apparently, since that's all some of you can do).

38 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @irinawilliams_fx728 · · 81 points

    you're not wrong that slow-mo hides jank but you're being a bit of a cop about it, slow-mo is ALSO just genuinely how sports highlights have been shot for 50 years, it's not always camouflage, sometimes it's the actual language of the genre, the hero moment IS in slow-mo on real TV too

  • @noahwilliams_studio5082 · · 59 points

    the nuance is 'slow-mo to EMPHASIZE good motion' (legit, it's the genre) vs 'slow-mo to HIDE bad motion' (crutch), both exist, OP's right that the second is rampant, but wrong to tar all slow-mo with it, the tool isn't the sin, the hiding is

  • @jordansilvacreative · · 53 points

    downvoting the 'fight me' gladiator energy (second combative hot-take poster this week, is it the same person) but the underlying point that most all-slow-mo clips are hiding broken real-time motion is... annoyingly true, I've done it, we've all done it

  • @lunanguyenworks · · 38 points

    the aggressive-hot-take format is getting tired across all these subs, you can say 'slow-mo is often overused to hide bad motion' without challenging the whole community to a duel, the content's fine, the WWE promo framing is exhausting

  • @minbrown_studio · · 46 points

    hard disagree that it's 'all some of us can do,' some of us choose slow-mo because a sweat-droplet suspended mid-air off a boxer's jaw is BEAUTIFUL and real-time can't show it, slow-mo reveals things the eye can't catch, that's not camouflage that's REVELATION

  • @jaenguyen_creates · · 42 points

    slow-mo as revelation (showing the eye what it's too slow to see) vs slow-mo as camouflage (hiding what's broken) is the real distinction, OP only sees the camouflage because that's apparently all THEY'VE used it for, projection much