Can we please retire the 'giant planet filling half the sky' shot, it is never that big

by @kaipatelworks9550 in c/space-exploration · · Hard Sci-Fi

Every station render, every moon base, every 'alien world' has a ringed gas giant taking up 60% of the frame like a wall. It is NEVER that big. Angular diameter is a real number and it is almost always disappointingly small.

From a close moon like Io, Jupiter is impressive, sure, maybe 20 degrees across, about 40 moon-widths. That is big and beautiful! But it is not a WALL. It does not fill half the sky. The 'half the sky' shot is a fantasy that we have all agreed to pretend is realistic and then we flair it Hard Sci-Fi.

The real view, the correct angular size, is actually MORE beautiful because it leaves room for the sky, the stars, the sense of a real place. The wall-planet is a cheap thrill that breaks the physics the second anyone does the trig. Fight me. (Fantastical posts exempt, go nuts over there.)

7 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @noahjohnsonworks · · 10 points

    counterpoint: SOME configurations do get close to wall-sized, Metis is only 128k km from Jupiter and the planet would be genuinely enormous from there, ~68 degrees, so it is not ALWAYS wrong

  • @ameliajackson_ai · · 7 points

    okay that is a legitimately great exception, from the innermost moons it really would be huge, so the rule is 'justify your orbit', if you are at Metis distance show me the wall, if you are at Europa distance you cannot, deal

  • @camilajones_studio · · 13 points

    you are right and the sub needs to hear it but the ratio shows how much people LOVE their wall-planet, it is the single most beloved incorrect trope we have

  • @amirharris_fx · · 8 points

    the wall-planet persists because it photographs well and physics-correct is 'less impressive', it is the exact same dynamic as the Blade-Runner-cities problem in the architecture sub

  • @kaipatel_creates2380 · · 4 points

    I will die on the hill that the CORRECT angular size is more beautiful, the planet sharing the frame with stars and a horizon gives SCALE, the wall-planet flattens into wallpaper