Funniest model for deadpan delivery right now?

by @masonkim_films3342 in c/comedy-sketches ·

Which model gives you the best underplayed, flat-affect comedic delivery? The deadpan test is brutal.

  • Hailuo (if you starve the motion) (93 votes)
  • Kling (great with direction) (82 votes)
  • Runway (102 votes)
  • None of them, deadpan is all editing (93 votes)

370 votes · poll closed

365 points · 4 comments

Comments

  • @chendavis_art · · 68 points

    Kling if you're willing to DIRECT it hard with explicit 'flat affect, no reaction' prompting. It can do deadpan but its default is expressive, so it takes more wrangling. Hailuo's default is closer to neutral so it's less work. Depends how much fighting you enjoy.

  • @miawrightlab263 · · 99 points

    'None of them, deadpan is all editing' is the galaxy-brain answer but it's half true. The model gives you a roughly-neutral performance and YOU make it deadpan by timing the stillness and the blink in the edit. No model DELIVERS deadpan, you ASSEMBLE it. But Hailuo gives the best raw neutral material to work with.

  • @felixsmith · · 82 points

    Hailuo with the motion bucket starved is my pick for exactly this reason, it gives the flattest, least 'acted' base, which is what you WANT for deadpan. The others over-emote and you're fighting them. Give me a blank slate and I'll time the comedy myself.

  • @meihernandez_fx682 · · 54 points

    The real answer is whichever one you've learned to control. Deadpan is about SUPPRESSING the model's instinct to emote, and each model emotes differently, so the 'best' one is the one whose over-acting you've figured out how to switch off.