Feedback wanted: narrative MV about a guy who can't leave a diner, does the loop read or just confuse?

by @sergeiwatanabecreative351 in c/music-videos · · Narrative

3-minute narrative MV for a slow indie track. Concept: a man keeps trying to leave a diner and every time he reaches the door he's back at the booth. The loop tightens, the diner decays, by the end it's clear he's the only customer and maybe always has been.

My worry is legibility. Narrative in an MV is tricky because you're serving the SONG's structure, not a plot's. I timed the loops to the verses and the 'reveal' to the bridge. But early test viewers split, half got it as a poignant trapped-in-grief thing, half just thought the edit was repetitive and got bored.

Is the ambiguity working for me or against me? Should the decay be more aggressive earlier so people clock 'this is intentional, something's wrong' sooner? Feedback wanted, link in a reply, roast it.

129 points · 9 comments

Comments

  • @anastasiaclark_fx · · 73 points

    the problem isn't ambiguity, it's that you don't SIGNAL intention early enough. the audience needs to know by the end of verse one that the repetition is the point, not a mistake. one clear 'wrong' detail in the first loop (a clock running backward, his coffee refilling itself) tells them to lean in instead of checking out.

  • @ravisilva_creates · · 48 points

    this is exactly it. 'repetitive' vs 'hypnotic loop' is decided in the first 30 seconds by whether the viewer TRUSTS that you're doing it on purpose. plant the flag early.

  • @sakurabrown_vfx4229 · · 42 points

    i watched it and the decay is too subtle until it's too late. by the time i noticed the diner falling apart i'd already half-written it off. push the decay 40 percent harder and start it in loop two.

  • @lunapatel_creates7154 · · 28 points

    agreed on the decay timing. the song gives you the bridge for the big reveal but the VISUAL rot should outpace the song a little so the picture is ahead of the audience's dawning realization.

  • @kaisinghworks8599 · · 30 points

    honestly i was in the 'bored' camp and the fixes in this thread would've flipped me. the concept is genuinely good, the EXECUTION is just under-signaling. not a concept problem.

  • @avamillerworks9155 · · 5 points

    downvoting the diner-loop concept because we've seen it a hundred times, but your decay idea is the fresh part, lean into the ROT being the story, not the loop

  • @jordangarciaworks · · 25 points

    disagree it's overdone, the loop is a vehicle, the decay and the 'always been alone' reveal is what's yours. the vehicle being familiar is fine.