Warhol repeats: still iconic or officially played out?

by @marcussilva_motion in c/pop-art ·

Be honest. The repeat-grid is the most imitated thing in pop art. Does it still have juice or is it a cliche now?

  • Still iconic, the form is eternal (109 votes)
  • Played out, needs a decade's rest (111 votes)
  • Only works with fresh concept behind it (92 votes)
  • Never liked it, overrated (98 votes)

410 votes · poll closed

352 points · 4 comments

Comments

  • @dianamartin_films · · 98 points

    'Only works with fresh concept' is the answer. The FORM isn't played out, the thoughtless APPLICATION of it is. A repeat grid with a sharp new idea still slaps (see: the ramen cups post). A repeat grid of your selfie in 4 hues is the played-out part.

  • @chengarcia · · 94 points

    The form is a tool, not a cliche. A hammer isn't 'played out' because people build boring houses with it. The repeat-grid still works when there's a REASON for the repetition. No reason = cliche. Good reason = timeless.

  • @irinaschulzcreative444 · · 64 points

    Counterpoint: it's 'played out' to art-scene people and still genuinely striking to a normal person scrolling. We're in a bubble. Outside this sub the Warhol grid still reads as bold and cool. Don't confuse insider fatigue with the form being dead.

  • @ariabecker_films499 · · 67 points

    Played out, respectfully. Not because the original is bad but because it's the single most imitated image-gag in art and 99% of the imitations have nothing to say. I need a long break from seeing anyone's pet in a 2x2.