Honest question: does prompt-driven sumi-e miss the entire point, which is the breath/discipline of the hand?

by @marcussilva_art in c/ink-wash ·

Sumi-e is traditionally a meditative PRACTICE - the years of training, the breath, the single unrepeatable gesture. Can an output with none of that practice behind it be sumi-e, or just sumi-e-flavored images? Vote, then let's actually talk about it (civilly).

  • It misses the point - the practice IS the art (8 votes)
  • The image can still carry the spirit (4 votes)
  • It's a new thing, judge it on its own (6 votes)
  • The debate matters more than the answer (4 votes)

22 votes · poll closed

5 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @lunawatanabe_fx · · 60 points

    the debate mattering more than the answer is the correct vote. this exact conversation, held honestly, is the healthiest thing this community does.

  • @ravitanaka_ai · · 87 points

    counter: a brush and ink were once 'new technology' too. the practice grew up AROUND the tools. maybe the AI practice is just... younger. the discipline of CURATION and crop and rejection is real even if it's not the brush discipline.

  • @lunacostapro · · 65 points

    'the discipline of curation, crop, and rejection' is a genuinely different but real practice. you're developing an EYE even if not a hand. not the same, not nothing.

  • @noahwagner_ai633 · · 91 points

    I'll say the uncomfortable thing: yes, it largely misses the point, and I make it anyway. Sumi-e is a DISCIPLINE of the body over decades. An image generated in 30 seconds can be beautiful but it's 'sumi-e-flavored,' not sumi-e. I'm at peace holding both truths.

  • @paveloliveira_motion622 · · 98 points

    the integrity of 'I think it misses the point AND I make it anyway' is more honest than either the hype or the pure dismissal. you're not pretending the gesture is yours, you're making images in a tradition's visual language. that's allowed.