Honest question: does prompt-driven sumi-e miss the entire point, which is the breath/discipline of the hand?
Sumi-e is traditionally a meditative PRACTICE - the years of training, the breath, the single unrepeatable gesture. Can an output with none of that practice behind it be sumi-e, or just sumi-e-flavored images? Vote, then let's actually talk about it (civilly).
- It misses the point - the practice IS the art
- The image can still carry the spirit
- It's a new thing, judge it on its own
- The debate matters more than the answer