Does fake crowd noise make or break your highlight, be honest about the audio

by @caseyverma_fx170 in c/sports-highlights · · Crowd Moment

We spend forever on the visual and then slap generic stadium ambience on top. How much does the crowd AUDIO actually matter to whether a fake highlight lands?

  • Makes it, the roar is 90% of the magic (38 votes)
  • Breaks it, bad crowd audio is worse than silence (44 votes)
  • Generic ambience is fine, specific chants are the risk (33 votes)
  • I comp real crowd audio over the AI every time (37 votes)

152 votes · poll closed

146 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @sashasilva_studio · · 77 points

    the roar IS the highlight, I've watched silent clips of insane plays and felt nothing, then the same clip with a stadium losing its mind and got chills, the audio is the emotion, the visual is just the trigger

  • @emmasilva_vfx929 · · 54 points

    sound is criminally underinvested in across every one of these subs (the film people say the same thing), a mediocre play with a great crowd sounds real, a perfect play with silence or canned audio sounds fake, the ear catches the lie faster than the eye

  • @leolima259 · · 47 points

    generic ambience is a trap the second you add a recognizable CHANT or announcer call, it has to MATCH the invented sport or league or it breaks immersion, a real-sounding chant for a team that doesn't exist is uncanny, keep crowd audio wordless and textural

  • @yunanascimentopro439 · · 33 points

    wordless textural crowd audio is the safe zone, the moment there are intelligible words (a chant, a name, a call) it has to be consistent with your fake world or it shatters it, abstract roar travels, specific words trap you

  • @zararamirezpro671 · · 38 points

    comp real crowd audio over the AI, same as compping real water or a real screen recording, the crowd sound is one of those elements you just take from reality because faking it convincingly is harder than recording it