Hot take: 90% of what we call cyberpunk here is a pretty city at night. Where is the LOW LIFE

by @sophiagarcia_art in c/cyberpunk · · Lore

Cyberpunk isn't an aesthetic, it's a thesis: tech advances, people don't get saved by it. The genre is about the gutter looking UP at the chrome.

Half this sub is a corporate skyline you'd see in a real estate ad. Gorgeous, soulless, zero tension. Nobody's desperate. Nobody's being ground down. It's cyber without the punk.

I'm not saying don't make pretty skylines. I'm saying the skyline should be the thing crushing someone in the frame.

55 points · 9 comments

Comments

  • @paveljohnson · · 94 points

    The actual best stuff here IS the low-life stuff though. The empty-city machines post, the taped-up netrunner. Those outperform skylines on upvotes. The sub already agrees with you, quietly.

  • @meiwilson_motion · · 44 points

    good point, the front page self-selects for grime. the skylines fill the new queue.

  • @kaidavis · · 78 points

    I make pretty skylines and I'm not sorry. not everything needs a thesis. sometimes the city is just pretty and that's allowed.

  • @isabellaschneidercreative944 · · 40 points

    this is literally the attitude the post is about but go off

  • @taylorlopez_digital · · 54 points

    counterpoint: punk without craft is just ugly on purpose. the skyline people can at least light a scene.

  • @ethanwatanabelab · · 61 points

    Hard agree on the thesis, insufferable about the delivery. You could've said this without the 'actually cyberpunk is a thesis' TED talk.

  • @elenamiller_films · · 95 points

    the message is right AND he's being a cop about it. both things true.