Hot take: most 'AI comedy' here is a funny IMAGE, not a joke, and the upvotes reward the wrong thing

by @henrythompson_motion307 in c/comedy-sketches ·

Said with love, but the incentives on this sub are broken. A striking funny IMAGE (pigeon in a suit, a cat CEO) gets 2000 upvotes in an hour. A tightly WRITTEN sketch with real setup/misdirect/punchline gets 200 and sinks. We're training ourselves to make greeting cards, not comedy.

A joke has ARCHITECTURE. Setup, misdirection, a turn, a landing. It happens over TIME. A funny image is a single gag, it's the visual equivalent of a pun, over the instant you get it. Both are fine! But they're not the same thing, and this is a SKETCH sub, and the sketch-craft is getting drowned out by easy visual gags because the visual gags are cheaper to make and faster to upvote.

The pigeon-hostage script, the HR Greg bits, the name-forgetting musical, THAT'S the craft this sub should elevate. Instead the front page is a parade of 'what if [animal] but [job]' images. We can do better. Reward the writing.

107 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @quinnrodriguez_digital546 · · 96 points

    As a maker of exactly the 'what if animal but job' content you're dragging: I feel seen and attacked and I'm going to go write an actual sketch with a real punchline now out of spite. Congratulations, your condescending hot take worked on me specifically.

  • @chencosta_creates · · 97 points

    Counterpoint: a great funny image IS a joke, it's just a joke in a different form (the visual pun, the single-panel gag). Gary Larson built a legend on single funny images. Don't gatekeep 'joke' to mean 'thing with a 90-second temporal structure'. A perfect visual gag is comedy too.

  • @olgaharrislab826 · · 75 points

    Far Side defense is valid, the single-panel gag is a real and hard comedic form. But OP's point stands that it's a DIFFERENT form than the sketch, and a SKETCH sub drowning in single-panel gags has a focus problem. Both are comedy. Only one is a sketch. Flair accordingly.

  • @emmasharma_films735 · · 94 points

    You're right about the craft hierarchy and wrong to blame the audience. Visual gags get more upvotes because they're INSTANT, you get the joke in the thumbnail and upvote while scrolling. A written sketch requires 90 seconds of attention before you know it's good. That's not broken incentives, that's just how attention works. Make peace with it.

  • @chendavis_ai632 · · 98 points

    The upvote-while-scrolling dynamic is real and unfixable. A great sketch COMPETES with a funny thumbnail for the same split-second attention, and the thumbnail wins because it pays off instantly. It's not that people value writing less, it's that they never make it to the writing. The format punishes depth.