WIP: tiny diorama-in-a-bottle. The glass is beating me. Critique the comp before I commit.

by @miaguptalab in c/low-poly · · WIP

Trying to do a classic low-poly world-in-a-bottle: a little island, a lighthouse, a boat, all inside a faceted glass bottle. The ISLAND is great. The glass is the problem - it either looks like a smooth blob (wrong) or it disappears entirely.

How do you do faceted/stylized glass that still reads as glass? A soft smooth material fights the whole low-poly vibe. Leaning toward a very low-opacity faceted shell with a single hard specular triangle. Thoughts before I lock it?

25 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @yukimueller_films · · 100 points

    Faceted glass is a real puzzle. The low-opacity shell + ONE hard specular hit is the right call. Glass reads from its highlights, not its transparency. Give it one confident faceted glint and the brain fills in 'glass.'

  • @zaramuellerworks · · 70 points

    'glass reads from its highlights not its transparency' - this unlocked it for me, thank you. one glint, low-opacity shell, done.

  • @sakuramuellercreative · · 55 points

    don't make the glass too dark or it fights the diorama inside. you want it almost invisible with just those two highlight cues. let the island be the star.

  • @zarawagnerpro · · 40 points

    the lighthouse better be like 20 triangles max or I'm calling the budget police

  • @victormuellerlab · · 44 points

    it's 16. tower is a tapered cube, light is one glowing tri. the police can stand down.