My perfume bottle demo looks great but the liquid inside moves like gel, feedback wanted

by @ravipatel_films9804 in c/product-demos · · Feedback Wanted

Hero shot of a perfume bottle, slow push-in, the bottle slowly tilts and the liquid inside catches the light. Everything's beautiful EXCEPT the liquid, which sloshes like it's hair gel or honey. It has too much viscosity, it moves thick and slow and clingy when perfume should be thin and quick and splashy.

I think the model defaults to a 'generic liquid' that's weirdly viscous, maybe because most training footage of 'liquid in a bottle being tilted' is oil or syrup ads? Perfume, water, alcohol, anything thin, comes out gloopy.

Anyone cracked thin-liquid behavior? I've tried 'thin watery liquid, low viscosity, quick movement' and it helps maybe 20%. The gloop persists. Current shot in comments, the bottle's perfect, the gel-perfume is killing the premium feel.

228 points · 9 comments

Comments

  • @sashanascimento_vfx · · 74 points

    the gloop is a real and specific model bias, you're right that 'liquid tilting in a vessel' training data skews toward syrup/oil/honey beauty shots because those are the most FILMED liquids, thin liquids barely register, so it averages to gloop

  • @sashasantos_vfx · · 57 points

    the fix that works for me: don't show much movement at all, perfume in a near-still bottle with just a tiny meniscus shift reads correct, the gloop only shows up when you ask for MOTION, so minimize the motion, a slow tilt with barely-moving liquid

  • @sashawagner_vfx · · 41 points

    'low viscosity' barely working tracks, viscosity words are weak levers, the model doesn't really have a viscosity dial, it has a 'vibe of liquid' and the default vibe is thick, you have to fight it structurally not with adjectives

  • @jordancostalab · · 29 points

    adjectives are weak, structure is strong, this is true across all these models, 'make it thin' loses to 'don't show it moving,' show-don't-tell even applies to prompting

  • @liamcosta_studio · · 47 points

    try generating the liquid as a SEPARATE element with real water reference and comping it into the masked bottle, the full-scene generation always gloops but an isolated water sim prompt behaves better, then marry them

  • @chenchen_studio1377 · · 33 points

    separating the liquid is overkill for most shots but for a HERO perfume push-in where the liquid is the star, yeah, give it its own element and direct it