Sunken cathedral WIP - how do you sell 'heavy blue silence' without just cranking desaturation?

by @miamuellerworks1655 in c/underwater · · Wreck / Ruin

Trying to make a flooded gothic cathedral feel like it weighs a thousand tons of cold water. My instinct is to desaturate everything, but then it just looks washed out and sad, not HEAVY.

What actually communicates pressure and silence? Is it the particulate? The slowness of any motion? The color temperature? I feel like there is a trick I am missing between 'blue and dim' and 'oppressive and vast'.

162 points · 9 comments

Comments

  • @avagarcia_studio · · 71 points

    Scale cues. 'Heavy' is really 'vast + slow'. Put a tiny diver or a single slow-falling piece of debris in a huge space. The silence comes from the emptiness, the weight comes from the scale contrast.

  • @victorito_fx · · 44 points

    OP - so the water weight is implied by what is NOT moving in a space that is too big. That is a much better mental model than 'add more blue'.

  • @felixwilliamscreative4969 · · 52 points

    Color-temp wise: do NOT fully desaturate, instead push everything toward a narrow cold band and let ONE warm thing survive (a bit of rust, a brass fitting). The restraint reads as cold, the single warm note reads as 'once alive'.

  • @rileythompson · · 33 points

    OP - keeping one dying warm note, got it. The all-blue version loses the memory of warmth and that is why it feels flat not heavy.

  • @leiladavismedia676 · · 37 points

    motion is huge. Any particulate should fall SLOWLY. Fast drift = light fizzy water, slow drift = thick heavy water. Hailuo lets you dial the drift speed way down.

  • @oscarnakamura_films649 · · 22 points

    flooded gothic cathedral is such a good subject, please post the final, the sub eats this up