Figure study: finally getting believable hands by NOT prompting hands

by @liamchenworks8563 in c/oil-painting · · Figure

Counterintuitive but: every time I prompt 'detailed hands, five fingers, anatomically correct' I get the cursed claw. Every time.

What works: compose so the hands are doing something — gripping a staff, resting on a knee, half in shadow. 'A hand loosely curled around a wooden staff, fingers in soft shadow.' Give it a verb and a context, not an anatomy lecture. The model has way more good training data of hands-doing-things than hands-as-subject.

Also: hands in the painterly-loose zone of the composition, not the sharp focal zone. A slightly unresolved hand reads as artistic. A sharp wrong hand reads as horror.

591 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @andresharma_fx · · 99 points

    'a slightly unresolved hand reads as artistic, a sharp wrong hand reads as horror' — this is the whole hand problem in one line. Keep them loose and in shadow.

  • @alexanderramirez_art · · 88 points

    This is literally what portrait painters did for centuries btw. Hands are hard IRL too so they buried them in shadow or draped a cloth. We reinvented the old cheat.

  • @emmamillercreative · · 54 points

    give it a verb and a context not an anatomy lecture — saving this phrasing

  • @oliviasilva_vfx855 · · 46 points

    counterpoint it still gave me six fingers but one was in shadow so I guess that's 'artistic' now

  • @priyalewis_art · · 71 points

    the sixth finger is just a pentimento. very old master of you.