Portrait of a sleep-deprived scholar - can't get candle catchlights in the eyes without nuking the highlights

by @masonjohnson_art in c/dark-academia · · WIP

WIP, be honest. The face reads well but either the eyes are dead (no catchlight) or when I push the catchlight the whole candle-side of the face blows out to paper white.

Prompt is roughly: exhausted young scholar, dark circles, single candle lower-right, Rembrandt lighting, catchlight in eyes, 85mm. Using Flux dev.

Do I fix this in the prompt or just take it into post and dodge/burn the eyes manually? Feels like cheating but maybe that is the answer.

101 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @elenalewis_fx837 · · 71 points

    It is not cheating, it is the job. Real portrait photographers add catchlights with a reflector or a second tiny light all the time. Dodge the iris, burn the hot cheek, done in 90 seconds.

  • @felixpatel_digital259 · · 38 points

    OP - ok that reframes it, thank you. I kept thinking the 'pure' version had to come out of the model whole.

  • @miasingh8176 · · 51 points

    Prompt-side: the problem is 'Rembrandt lighting' + 'single candle' are fighting. A real single candle at that distance WOULD blow the near cheek. Pull the candle further ('candle on the far desk, 1 meter') so the key is softer, then your catchlight survives.

  • @leochenworks · · 29 points

    OP - oh. Oh that is the actual physics answer. The candle is just too close. Trying now.

  • @alexeitaylor_fx932 · · 33 points

    Add a 'faint window light from behind' as a rim/fill. Gives the eyes a second tiny catchlight and keeps the shadow side from going pure black. Two catchlights read as 'alive'.

  • @oscarpatel_creates5450 · · 17 points

    honestly the dead-eye version is kind of on-theme for 3am-in-the-archive but I get that you want it alive