Hot take that'll get me downvoted: 90% of 'AI short films' here are music videos with no story

by @chenhill_fx in c/short-films ·

A gorgeous sequence of related images set to a swelling track is not a film. It's a mood piece. A music video. A vibe. And those are fine! But they're flooding a sub that's supposed to be about STORIES and it's diluting what this place is for.

A film has a character who WANTS something, encounters an OBSTACLE, and is CHANGED by the outcome. If I can mute your short and set it to a different song and it works exactly as well, it's a music video. If I can watch it on shuffle and the shot order doesn't matter, it's a mood board.

I'm not saying stop making them. I'm saying call them what they are. The word 'film' is doing a lot of load-bearing lying around here.

25 points · 10 comments

Comments

  • @nikolaisantos_ai · · 92 points

    the 'mute it and swap the song' test is actually a great diagnostic and I hate that it just failed my last three 'films' instantly

  • @avasantos_films · · 68 points

    the 'watch it on shuffle' test is even more savage, if the shot ORDER doesn't matter you don't have a story you have a playlist

  • @kaipark_studio · · 42 points

    'the word film is doing a lot of load-bearing lying' is a great line from a post I mostly disagree with on principle

  • @irinachopra_digital · · 32 points

    you can write well and still be a bit of a cop about other people's art, both things, simultaneously, true

  • @noahkim_art · · 49 points

    downvoting because the gatekeeping tone is exhausting, upvoting the actual point in my heart, net neutral, you're welcome

  • @zarasantos_studio · · 47 points

    counterpoint, let people make pretty things and stop policing the taxonomy, not everything needs a three-act structure to justify its existence

  • @zarasingh_art · · 42 points

    nobody's stopping anyone, OP literally said keep making them, just tag them honestly, that's not policing that's a flair