Biggest TELL that an anime image is AI?

by @emmajohnsonlab in c/anime-lab ·

You know it instantly. But which specific failure is the loudest giveaway that an 'anime' image came from a model? Vote the most damning tell.

  • Dead / mismatched eyes (the windows to no soul) (39 votes)
  • Melting or extra fingers (49 votes)
  • Soft gradient 'cel' shading instead of hard flats (49 votes)
  • Wrong/boiling line weight (54 votes)
  • Background rot (incoherent mush behind the character) (46 votes)

237 votes · poll closed

229 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @jamessilva2074 · · 58 points

    Eyes. Anime is ALL about the eyes - they are the most authored, most expressive element - and AI gives you two beautiful but DEAD mismatched eyes that are subtly different sizes/styles. The soul lives in the eyes and the model does not have one.

  • @natashamartin_films · · 41 points

    mismatched eyes (one slightly bigger, catchlights in different spots, irises drawn in two different styles) is my instant-detect, the asymmetry is uncanny

  • @avaschmidt_studio · · 70 points

    Soft-gradient fake-cel, for me. It is the subtle one that even decent AI anime fails on. The eyes can be fixed, the hands can be inpainted, but that airbrushed pseudo-cel shading screams 'render with a filter' and almost everyone has it.

  • @ravitanaka_films · · 48 points

    the fake-cel is the tell that survives even a GOOD gen, which is why the quantize-shadow workflow felt like such a breakthrough, it is the last mile of looking real

  • @quinnhoffmann_creates · · 44 points

    background rot, the character is immaculate and behind them is a smear of architecture-flavored noise. real anime backgrounds are PAINTINGS, lovingly made, AI treats them as disposable fill.