Hot take: 90% of the 'workflows' posted here are trial-and-error with a flowchart taped on

by @sakuragarcia_studio in c/behind-the-scenes ·

Love this sub but let's be real. Half these 'pipelines' are someone drawing a box around 'I tried stuff until it worked' and calling it methodology.

A real workflow is reproducible. If you can't hand it to someone else and have them get a comparable result, it's not a workflow, it's your personal luck ritual with extra steps.

The seed-logging crowd gets it. The 'I vibe-prompt until it clicks' crowd dressing it up in a node graph does not. Prove me wrong, show me a process I can actually run.

81 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @kaichen_vfx · · 86 points

    Spicy but I half agree. The flowchart posts that don't include the PROMPTS are useless. Show the words or it didn't happen.

  • @victortanakalab · · 95 points

    Counterpoint: documenting your trial-and-error IS valuable even if it's not perfectly reproducible. The failed takes teach the next person where the walls are. That's the whole point of this sub.

  • @jasminetanaka_motion · · 86 points

    You're not wrong but you're being a jerk about it. Trial and error IS the process right now, the models aren't deterministic enough for anything else. We're all alchemists until the tools mature.

  • @noahtanakacreative · · 97 points

    This. 'Reproducible' assumes stable seeds and stable model versions. The provider silently updates the model and your 'reproducible workflow' evaporates overnight. Can't blame users for that.

  • @irissmith_digital89 · · 79 points

    Imagine gatekeeping 'workflow' in a field that's 18 months old. We're all figuring it out in public, that's the fun part.