Post-mortem: my festival-submitted AI short got rejected. Posting the full feedback letter, unedited

by @hanasantos9767 in c/short-films · · Feedback Wanted

I submitted to a mid-tier narrative festival. Rejected. But they sent an actual feedback letter, which almost never happens, and it's so useful I'm posting the whole thing (names removed).

The gist: they didn't reject it for being AI. They rejected it for the thing AI shorts almost always get dinged on, which is that the story 'served the images rather than the images serving the story.' Their words. They felt every shot existed because it was cool to generate, not because the narrative needed it. Ouch. Accurate. Ouch.

Second note: 'the ending resolves the plot but not the emotion.' I've been chewing on that for a week. Full letter in comments. If you're submitting AI work to festivals, this is the bar, and it's the right bar.

612 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @natashaking_digital931 · · 72 points

    'resolves the plot but not the emotion' is the kind of note that takes 8 words and six months to actually internalize. that's a masterclass note.

  • @nikolaisilvalab · · 43 points

    plot resolution is mechanical, emotional resolution is the actual movie, you can tie up every loose end and leave the audience cold. brutal and true.

  • @chensmith_studio · · 99 points

    'the story served the images rather than the images serving the story' is the exact diagnosis for 90% of what gets posted here and it's brave of you to publish your own rejection letter saying it about your own film.

  • @oliviajohnson_vfx · · 68 points

    the tail wagging the dog is the original sin of AI filmmaking, we make the shot because we CAN and then reverse-engineer a story to justify it

  • @lunasantos_films · · 48 points

    festivals sending ANY feedback is a unicorn, the fact that it's thoughtful feedback that happens to be dead-on makes this the most valuable post of the month

  • @meiking_films · · 39 points

    saving this because 'does this shot serve the story or does the story serve this shot' is now a question I'm going to ask about every single clip I generate