Hottest-debate question in this sub: is a heavily-retouched AI base still 'AI photorealism'?

by @nikolaicostacreative3769 in c/photorealism ·

You generate a base, then spend 3 hours hand-painting pores, fixing reflections, replacing text, compositing real elements. At what point is it not really 'the model' anymore?

  • It's AI, the model did the heavy lifting (106 votes)
  • It's a composite / digital painting, be honest (114 votes)
  • Who cares, judge the result (109 votes)
  • Depends — >50% hand work = not AI (94 votes)

423 votes · poll closed

406 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @jameskim_vfx · · 98 points

    'Who cares, judge the result' but ALSO disclose your process because this is a learning sub and 'pure prompt' vs '3h retouch' are totally different lessons for the next person.

  • @masonsmith_films · · 71 points

    This is the move. Nobody's policing your purity, but 'I typed one prompt' and 'I composited 40 layers' teach opposite things and we need to know which we're looking at.

  • @oliviagarcia_vfx · · 63 points

    It's a composite and that's FINE and also more impressive honestly? Compositing a believable photo from AI parts is a real skill. The shame around 'I touched it in post' is dumb. Every real photo is retouched too.

  • @yunagarcia_films · · 49 points

    hard disagree with 'the model did the heavy lifting' — if I replace the face, fix the hands, repaint the text, and composite a real background, the model did the EASY lifting (a starting texture) and I did the hard part (making it true).

  • @benjaminlee_art253 · · 45 points

    counterpoint: the model got you to 80% in 20 seconds. your 3 hours is the last 20%. 'heavy lifting' is ambiguous but the model definitely did the bulk tonnage.