How many colors does a sunset actually NEED? Settle the eternal war.

by @skylerlima_fx786 in c/pixel-art · · Palette Study

The sub's founding debate. You're doing a pixel sunset sky — ground to zenith gradient. How many colors is RIGHT? Not what's possible, what's correct.

  • 3 (true restraint, dither the gaps) (100 votes)
  • 5 (the classic sweet spot) (69 votes)
  • 8 (room to breathe) (71 votes)
  • 16 (you're not even trying to restrain) (88 votes)
  • As many as it takes — bands are a choice not a limit (70 votes)

398 votes · poll closed

387 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @ethanhoffmann_studio · · 96 points

    5 and dither the transitions. the whole SOUL of a pixel sunset is the dithered band between colors. if you use 16 you've removed the dithering, and the dithering was the art. you've just made a jpeg with big pixels.

  • @priyathompson694 · · 93 points

    'you've just made a jpeg with big pixels' is the most devastating thing you can say to someone's overly-smooth pixel gradient and it is correct every time

  • @dianajohnson_ai · · 81 points

    3 colors gang, rise up. you can do a BREATHTAKING sunset in 3 if you dither like your life depends on it. the constraint forces the creativity. 16 colors is just conceding you don't trust your dithering.

  • @harperschmidt_motion860 · · 53 points

    3 colors is a flex and a trap. when it works it's sublime, when it fails it's a checkerboard mess. high skill floor. respect the 3-color artists, pray for the 3-color beginners.

  • @andretanaka_studio · · 16 points

    controversial: bands are a CHOICE. a hard-banded sunset with zero dithering can look incredible and intentional. not everything needs to simulate a smooth gradient. the Lospec palettes with 4 colors and proud bands slap.

  • @rileytanakacreative · · 36 points

    this is the real schism — dither-to-fake-smoothness camp vs embrace-the-bands camp. both valid. it's a style question masquerading as a technique question.