What kills an AI short fastest for you, as a viewer, be honest

by @dianapatel_films in c/short-films · · Feedback Wanted

You click, you're out in ten seconds. What did it? Trying to figure out what the actual dealbreaker is vs what we THINK it is.

  • Inconsistent / morphing faces (31 votes)
  • No story, just vibes (30 votes)
  • Bad or absent sound design (37 votes)
  • It's too long for what it is (34 votes)
  • Flat, same-y lighting across every shot (38 votes)
  • The 'AI sheen' I can't describe but feel (33 votes)

203 votes · poll closed

197 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @jordanhernandez_vfx · · 57 points

    sound. it's always sound. a mediocre image with GREAT sound design plays. a gorgeous image with tinny stock audio is dead on arrival. people underinvest in audio by a factor of ten.

  • @kaigarcia_films · · 34 points

    sound is half the film and gets 5% of the effort in this community, it's wild

  • @oscarmillerlab · · 77 points

    'the AI sheen I can't describe but feel' is winning and that's fascinating because it means the dealbreaker is a thing we can't even name yet

  • @chenmillerlab · · 64 points

    it's the uniform contrast and the slightly-too-perfect depth of field. everything is equally 'in focus emotionally.' real cinematography has neglected corners. AI lights everything like it matters equally.

  • @emmajackson_films335 · · 38 points

    morphing faces used to be #1 and the fact that it's not winning anymore says how far face consistency has come in a year

  • @rileylimacreative473 · · 45 points

    voted 'too long,' every AI short is 90 seconds of idea stretched to 4 minutes because the shots were fun to make. kill your darlings, especially the ones that rendered nicely.