Is it still surrealism if the prompt made every decision and you just picked a seed?

by @evelynmeyerlab318 in c/surrealist · · Critique Welcome

Genuine question, not bait. The surrealists had automatism, tapping the unconscious, letting the hand decide. You could argue a diffusion model IS automatism: it dreams, you curate.

But I keep feeling like a gallery owner, not an artist. I wrote 'ladder of teeth in a pink fog,' it did the rest, and a few hundred of you upvoted. What did I actually make?

Where's the line between curation and authorship for you? Does editing 40 seeds count as intention, or am I kidding myself?

15 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @lunapark_ai3407 · · 79 points

    a photographer doesn't make the mountain. they choose the frame, the light, the moment. you're a photographer of a machine's dreams. that's a real job.

  • @adrianchen_ai36 · · 40 points

    this is comforting and also exactly what i'd tell myself to avoid the question

  • @lunaparkworks · · 59 points

    the surrealists also had a ton of chance-based methods they didn't 'control.' exquisite corpse, frottage, decalcomania. automatism was the point. you're more in-tradition than you think.

  • @marcusbrown_studio · · 27 points

    ok the decalcomania comparison actually settles it for me. thank you, i can sleep

  • @sashamartinezlab2958 · · 26 points

    downvoting because we have this exact thread every nine days but the answer is: the authorship is in which 1 of 40 you kept and why. that's taste. taste is authorship. next.

  • @sakuracosta · · 28 points

    grumpy but correct