When should you redesign a character instead of refining the original?
Characters often evolve as their creators improve. At some point the question comes up: keep polishing the first design, or start again with what you know now?
Creators tend to weigh a few things. If the silhouette and core idea still work, refining details usually keeps what people liked. If the design no longer fits the story or the art style, a redesign can be healthier. Some keep a few signature elements, a color, a shape or an accessory, so the new version still feels like the same character. And testing both versions in motion or in a scene often settles it.
Have you redesigned a character from scratch? What made you decide it was time, and what did you keep?