Your cinematic AI spot sounds fake because the audio is too clean, add the room back

by @jordannguyenworks in c/cinematic-ad-studio · · Sound / Music

I review a lot of 'cinematic' work here and the single most common reason a gorgeous spot feels cheap is the sound. The picture is film, the audio is a stock music bed and nothing else. No room, no air, no foley, no space.

Real spots are built in layers: room tone under everything, specific foley for every product interaction, a music bed that was CUT to the picture not just laid under it, and a final mix that carves space so nothing fights. Even a 15-second spot has a dozen audio layers.

Add room tone first. Just that. The silence between the music and the picture is where 'cheap' lives. Fill it with air and your spot gains a tax bracket. Happy to break down a reference mix if people want.

350 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @victorpatel_ai · · 68 points

    'fill it with air and your spot gains a tax bracket' i am stealing this for my sound design deck immediately

  • @ravikim_vfx · · 41 points

    take it, spread the gospel. clean audio is the uncanny valley of the ears.

  • @marcuskim_studio · · 51 points

    foley for a PRODUCT specifically is what nobody does. the cap click, the fabric, the liquid. AI gives you a silent object and a silent object reads as fake no matter how good the grade

  • @felixtanaka_fx · · 34 points

    a product that doesn't make sound isn't real in your lizard brain. foley is the believability layer.

  • @elenasilva_films · · 23 points

    would you use AI music beds at all or always license/compose? the AI music i've tried loops obviously and can't hit a cut

  • @mayapatel_studio · · 29 points

    AI music for scratch and mood exploration, never for delivery. it can't hit an accent on a specific frame, and hitting the cut is the whole point of a spot score. i compose the final or license and re-edit to picture.