WIP: orbital elevator anchor station, need brutal feedback on the scale cues

by @sashamehtaworks in c/sci-fi-concepts · · WIP

This is the counterweight station at the top of a space elevator, 36,000 km up. My problem: it doesn't read as enormous. People keep saying it looks like a cool satellite, not a structure with a city's worth of people living in it.

Things I've tried: tiny running lights (helps a little), a docked ship for scale (helps until you realize nobody knows how big the ship is either), atmospheric perspective on the far modules.

What am I missing? I feel like there's a trick to selling megastructure scale that I haven't figured out and it's driving me up a wall. Rough render in comments, roast it.

95 points · 9 comments

Comments

  • @olgawhite_creates707 · · 72 points

    Scale isn't about big things, it's about the smallest legible thing. Put ONE recognizable human-sized object (a window, a door, a parked shuttle you've seen the inside of) and let the eye multiply from there.

  • @nikolaijacksoncreative · · 48 points

    this. the brain can't scale off a satellite because a satellite has no familiar unit. give it a door.

  • @sakurasmithcreative · · 39 points

    gradient of detail. near modules sharp, mid modules softer, far modules almost silhouette. your render is uniformly sharp which flattens it.

  • @hanasingh_films1734 · · 43 points

    also structural logic. a thing that big needs to look like it's fighting gravity/tension. right now it floats like it weighs nothing. add sag, add cable tension, add the strain.

  • @jordansuzuki_studio569 · · 18 points

    the tension cables idea is so good, that's exactly what sells 'this is under load'

  • @ethansilvalab · · 21 points

    honestly it already looks great, you're being hard on yourself, but yeah the door thing will push it over the line