Studio rules: how to earn the Approved Studio flair, and why we gatekeep a little here

by @jaeschmidtworks in c/cinematic-ad-studio · · Mod Post

This is the pro bench. We hold work to a commercial bar, which means craft, not just output.

Approved Studio is for members who've posted three finished spots that cleared peer review. It's not a status badge, it's a 'this person can take a brief to delivery' signal. Apply in the monthly thread.

Every post needs intent. Finished Spot, Spec Ad, Treatment, Product Film, or a craft tag (Color / Grade, Sound / Music). 'Look what I made' with no brief, no product, no idea of the audience, gets removed. A spot sells something. Tell us what and to whom.

Feedback Wanted gets you real notes. We are blunt. If that's not what you want, don't use the flair.

No client names without permission. No passing off spec as delivered. We can tell.

484 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @chenking_digital962 · · 98 points

    the 'a spot sells something, tell us what and to whom' line is the best filter this sub has. kills the pretty-but-pointless posts instantly.

  • @felixsingh_vfx · · 73 points

    half the 'cinematic' AI work online is a mood board pretending to be an ad. there's no product and no promise. this sub is the only place that calls it.

  • @hanalee_art · · 28 points

    how strict is the three-spot bar for Approved Studio, asking for a nervous friend (me)

  • @diegochopra · · 34 points

    strict on craft, forgiving on budget. a clean low-budget spec that understands its brief beats a flashy one that doesn't. post, we'll tell you where you are.

  • @liamgarcia_studio · · 37 points

    appreciate a sub that gatekeeps for quality and not for clout. rare