Critique welcome: my bokeh looks pasted on, how do you integrate the light blur

by @yukisantos_creates in c/neon-nights · · Critique Welcome

Critique Welcome flair ON, genuinely want notes. My neon shots have nice bokeh (those big soft out-of-focus light circles in the background) but it always looks like I pasted a bokeh overlay on top, which, honestly, sometimes I did. It sits ON the image instead of being OF the image.

What I think is wrong but want confirmed: the bokeh circles are all the same size and same brightness and perfectly round, like a stock overlay. And they do not interact with anything, they just float. How do you make AI bokeh feel like it is actually the background of THIS scene and not a layer from a pack?

64 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @masonsmithworks6894 · · 38 points

    real bokeh VARIES, the circles are different sizes (based on how far each light is), different brightnesses, and the ones at the edge of the frame are CAT'S-EYE shaped (lens vignetting squishes them), not round, that uniformity is your tell

  • @masonkimworks6831 · · 27 points

    the cat's-eye-at-the-edges thing is the detail that will fix it instantly, perfectly round bokeh all the way to the corners is physically impossible and the brain knows, squish the edge ones

  • @oscarchen · · 20 points

    the other issue is DEPTH, generate the bokeh as part of the scene by prompting a wide aperture ('shot at f1.4, shallow depth of field, out of focus neon bokeh background') so the model renders it integrated instead of you compositing it after

  • @oscarjohnson_creates2145 · · 15 points

    prompting the aperture so the model bakes the bokeh in is better than any overlay because then the blur is CORRECT for the actual scene depth, the overlay never matches the real depth of the shot

  • @oscarmueller_films · · 13 points

    honestly half your problem is just that you ARE pasting it on (you said so), prompt it into the gen instead, the model's native bokeh is imperfect in the RIGHT ways, overlays are imperfect in the wrong ways