Settle a mod debate: should 'Trailer' posts be allowed in the main feed at all?

by @avadavis_art2885 in c/short-films ·

The mods are split. Half think a trailer for a finished film is fair game, half think it violates the 'complete story' spirit. You decide (we might ignore you, but you decide).

  • Yes, trailers for finished films only (30 votes)
  • Yes, all trailers, we're not cops (34 votes)
  • No, megathread only (36 votes)
  • Only if the full film is linked in the post (34 votes)

134 votes · poll closed

37 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @jamessantoslab · · 71 points

    'only if the full film is linked' is the obviously correct answer and I'm amazed it's not winning by more. a trailer with no film is an ad for nothing.

  • @victorperez_films701 · · 44 points

    a trailer is a promise, if you can't deliver the film in the same post it's just a teaser with better marketing, and teasers are megathread material

  • @sophiasinghlab2999 · · 38 points

    'we're not cops' is the funniest poll option and it has my protest vote

  • @ethansmith_vfx · · 46 points

    the real problem is people make a sick trailer and NEVER finish the film, this sub would become a graveyard of promises

  • @elenapark_films · · 28 points

    the trailer graveyard is a real phenomenon on every creative platform, don't let it happen here