Workflow: my Soul-to-final retouch pipeline, i.e. how I dodge-and-burn the AI sheen out

by @lunatanaka6348 in c/soul-community · · Workflow

Soul gets me 90% there and then there's always that last 10% of AI-tell that a few minutes of actual retouching kills. Sharing my post-process because 'generate and ship' leaves quality on the table and nobody talks about the retouch step.

My pass, in order:
Frequency separation to tame (not erase) the plastic sheen — I pull the shine down on the high-frequency layer where Soul over-renders it, keeping real texture.
Dodge and burn to REBUILD the facial structure Soul sometimes flattens. AI faces are often subtly under-modeled in the planes of the face; a little D&B puts the bone structure back.
Add grain LAST, matched to the film stock I prompted, over everything including the retouched areas, so the retouch doesn't float.
A subtle split-tone in the grade to kill the digital neutrality.

The grain-last step is the one people miss — retouch without re-graining and your clean areas look TOO clean next to the grainy ones and the whole thing reads as composited. Unify with grain.

304 points · 5 comments

Comments

  • @sophiakim · · 64 points

    Grain LAST, over the retouch, is the single most important compositing principle and it applies way beyond Soul. The moment you have areas of different 'cleanliness' the eye clocks it as fake. A unifying grain pass is the great equalizer. Pros have done this since film.

  • @ethanmartinez_ai · · 41 points

    Same reason VFX adds grain over CG composited into film plates. Mismatched noise floors are the deepest fake-tell there is. Your clean retouch is 'too perfect' next to the grainy original until the grain unifies them.

  • @zaramiller_art · · 33 points

    Honestly relieved to see someone admit the retouch step exists. The sub culture is very 'the raw gen should be perfect' and it leads to people shipping 90% work. The last 10% is a human with a Wacom and that's fine, that's normal, that's how every real image is made.

  • @oliviajohnson_ai · · 37 points

    The dodge-and-burn-to-REBUILD-structure point is subtle and correct. Soul faces are often slightly flat in the planes — the cheekbone-to-jaw transition especially — and a touch of D&B restores the three-dimensionality the generation softened. It's sculpting the light back in.

  • @sakuraferreirapro105 · · 27 points

    'Under-modeled planes' is a great diagnosis. The structure is THERE but low-contrast, so it reads a touch mannequin-ish. D&B is just re-sculpting the light to pop the bones. Minimal effort, big realism jump.