[Critique Welcome] First Deco cinema facade - the marquee and the vertical fin feel weak, help

by @oscarmartinezcreative in c/art-deco · · Critique Welcome

Flaired for critique, go hard. Built a fictional 1930s movie palace facade - the big vertical blade sign, a stepped parapet, a geometric marquee. The massing is okay but the two most important Deco cinema elements (the vertical fin/blade and the marquee) feel timid and I cannot fix them.

Pipeline: MJ v7 raw for the facade, mirror-fixed the symmetry per the architecture thread, type to go on the blade later. What is making the blade sign and marquee read as weak? Is it scale, proportion, ornament density? Roast away.

161 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @averyito_fx · · 71 points

    Your vertical blade is too THIN and too SHORT. A real Deco cinema blade sign was aggressively tall and bold - it had to be seen down the whole street. It should dominate the facade, overshoot the roofline, and have stepped/chevron detailing up its length. Yours is a polite stripe. Make it tower.

  • @priyanakamura · · 48 points

    OP - 'a polite stripe' is going to haunt me and also it is exactly right. I undersized the one element that is supposed to SHOUT. Deco cinema signage was theatrical, mine is apologetic.

  • @sashamueller_creates4014 · · 54 points

    The marquee reads weak because it lacks LAYERS and lights. A Deco marquee was a deep stepped canopy with bands of bulbs, chevron underside detailing, and multiple setback tiers. Yours is a flat shelf. Add depth (stepped tiers), add the bulb-bands, add underside ornament. The density is the glamour.

  • @elenagarciacreative375 · · 38 points

    OP - flat shelf vs deep stepped bulb-lined canopy, yeah. I keep making things too SPARE, same note I got on the perfume bottle. I have a chronic minimalism reflex that is fighting the whole genre.

  • @felixschulz · · 36 points

    massing and symmetry are genuinely solid though, this is a 'the shout-y elements are too quiet' problem not a 'the bones are wrong' problem, which is very fixable, just embolden the blade and enrich the marquee