WIP: trying to get AI to do a convincing BORING landscape and it refuses, everything's epic

by @kaiwilliamscreative in c/travel-reels · · Nature / Landscape

Weird WIP problem for notes. I want to make a QUIET, ordinary, slightly dull landscape reel, a flat midwestern field, a gray overcast sky, a two-lane road, a grain silo. The beauty of the mundane, the poetry of nowhere-in-particular. And the models will NOT let me. Every gen turns my boring field into an EPIC field, god rays, dramatic clouds, impossible golden light, a lone tree backlit like a car commercial.

The training data is so biased toward 'epic beautiful landscape' that 'ordinary' is almost impossible to reach. I prompt 'flat, dull, overcast, unremarkable, gray, ordinary, no drama' and it gives me a slightly-less-epic-but-still-epic field. It cannot comprehend that I want it to be BORING on purpose. Boring is apparently out of distribution.

I think there's something profound and sad here about what these models think the world looks like, they've learned that landscapes are always spectacular, because only the spectacular ones get photographed and posted. The ordinary world is underrepresented in the data and therefore nearly ungeneratable. Anyone cracked deliberate, poetic MUNDANITY? WIP, genuinely stuck.

135 points · 10 comments

Comments

  • @elenasantos_vfx · · 71 points

    this is accidentally one of the most interesting posts on the sub, you've discovered that the models literally cannot imagine an ordinary world because we only photograph the extraordinary one. 'boring is out of distribution' is a genuinely profound observation about the gap between the world and its image online. the models learned a planet that's always at golden hour.

  • @elenakim_films · · 51 points

    the models think Earth is permanently spectacular because the DATA is permanently spectacular, nobody uploads the gray tuesday field. you're asking it to render the 99 percent of reality that never gets posted. it has barely seen the ordinary world. that's a haunting thing to realize.

  • @yunahernandez_fx836 · · 44 points

    practical fix: generate the epic version then CRUSH it in post, flatten the contrast, desaturate, dull the sky, remove the drama in the grade. it's easier to take the epic OUT than to prompt it away. fake boring by subtracting spectacle.

  • @ameliaweber_digital · · 28 points

    subtracting the epic in post is the realpolitik answer, the model won't give you boring so make epic and degrade it toward ordinary. flatten, gray, dull. manufactured mundanity.

  • @jordandavis_art · · 33 points

    try negative-prompting the drama HARD, 'dramatic light, god rays, golden hour, epic, cinematic, lens flare, backlit' all in the negative. you have to actively forbid the spectacle because it's the default. forbid epic to find ordinary.

  • @lunagarcia_creates · · 26 points

    negative-prompting 'cinematic' and 'epic' to achieve realism is such a funny inversion of how everyone else prompts, but for mundanity it's exactly right. the rest of us beg for epic, you have to ban it.