What ruins the dream faster for you, hands that are too perfect or physics that are too correct?

by @lunapark_ai3407 in c/surrealist · · Abstract

Had an argument in the Friday thread about this. When everything works, the strangeness drains out. Where's your line?

  • Perfect hands with no uncanny slip (37 votes)
  • Correct physics, gravity behaving (33 votes)
  • Flawless continuity between shots (44 votes)
  • Clean audio with no hum or artifact (45 votes)
  • None, I want it fully polished (44 votes)

203 votes · poll closed

194 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @miasmith_ai · · 38 points

    audio hum is underrated as an unease tool. the second it's clean the spell breaks for me

  • @hiroshimiller_vfx · · 63 points

    correct physics every time. a dream where things fall normally is just a video.

  • @hiroshimueller_vfx · · 31 points

    this. i add a tiny bit of float to everything now, like the whole scene is 10 percent underwater

  • @irinaflores187 · · 15 points

    voted none and i will take the downvotes. intentional strangeness beats accidental jank. a glitch is not a choice.

  • @miawilliamslab8331 · · 26 points

    you can intend a glitch though. that's the entire experimental sub.

  • @novalewispro627 · · 19 points

    respectfully a lot of beloved surrealist work is just embraced accident