The secret to a believable crowd reaction is the 0.5 seconds BEFORE the play, not after
Everyone obsesses over the crowd EXPLODING after the big moment. But the thing that actually sells it is the crowd BEFORE. The tension. The lean-forward. The held breath. The guy with his hands on his head already, anticipating. If the crowd is passive and neutral right up until the play and THEN erupts, it reads as a switch flipping, fake.
Real crowds are a living pressure system. On a big play developing, you can see the anticipation BUILD, people rising from their seats BEFORE the shot lands, the collective lean, the murmur swelling. The eruption is just the release of a tension you have to BUILD FIRST.
So now I animate the crowd in two stages: the BUILD (0.5-1s before the play, rising tension, people standing, hands coming up) and the RELEASE (the eruption). Skip the build and the release has nothing to release. The anticipation is the foundation the celebration stands on. Clips comparing with/without the build in comments, the difference is night and day.