Announcement: Soul ID v2 is rolling out — read this before you post 'my character changed'

by @ravismith in c/soul-community · · Announcement

Mod + staff note. Soul ID v2 is live for most accounts this week. Short version of what changed and why your old IDs might look different:

v2 holds identity MUCH better across extreme angles and expressions, but it's more faithful to your SOURCE references, so if your reference set was inconsistent (mixed lighting, mixed ages, one bad photo), v2 will now honor that mess instead of averaging it away like v1 did. Garbage in is now more visibly garbage out. Re-curate your reference sets.

Also: v2 reads skin texture from your references harder. If your refs were over-smoothed, your outputs will be too. Feed it real-texture references and it rewards you.

Known issue being worked on: profile/side views still drift more than frontal. Thread for that is pinned second. Don't spam new bug posts, add to the mega-thread.

193 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @takeshicostalab · · 58 points

    'Garbage in is now more visibly garbage out' is going to cause a week of chaos as everyone realizes their reference sets were always bad and v1 was hiding it. Honestly good. Rip the bandaid.

  • @yukinguyen_studio · · 41 points

    The number of people about to discover their 'consistent character' was v1 papering over five mismatched reference photos is going to be comedy. The averaging was a crutch.

  • @dianamueller · · 70 points

    STAFF: to be crystal clear, v2 holding your references more faithfully is a FEATURE. v1's 'helpful averaging' is why everyone's characters slowly drifted toward the same generic pretty face. v2 keeps what makes your character specific. Curate accordingly.

  • @miatanaka_art · · 44 points

    Can confirm the texture-faithfulness. Swapped my smoothed refs for raw ones with visible pores and v2 outputs went from mannequin to human instantly. The references ARE the texture budget now.

  • @kai_stills · · 29 points

    Profile drift being a KNOWN issue is validating, I thought I was losing my mind. Adding my repro to the mega-thread now instead of making the duplicate post I was about to make. You're welcome mods.

  • @minyoung588 · · 22 points

    This is the way. One good mega-thread with repros beats forty 'anyone else?' posts. Staff can actually act on a consolidated report.