Everything I learned making a 40-shade black-on-black piece (Ad Reinhardt was right)

by @nikolaigarciacreative in c/abstract-art · · Monochrome

Spent two weeks on a monochrome piece that's 'just' black, and it taught me more about value than anything I've made. The goal: a field of near-blacks, 40+ barely-distinguishable dark tones, where forms only emerge if you really LOOK (and have a good monitor).

Hard-won lessons:
The model HATES subtle value. Ask for 'black on black' and it either gives you flat black or cranks the contrast to make the forms 'readable'. It wants legibility; I wanted the opposite.
Had to generate at higher brightness, then crush everything into the near-black range in post while preserving the micro-variations. The model can't work in the narrow value band, so I compress into it after.
Compression artifacts are the ENEMY. Banding in the near-blacks destroys the subtle gradients. Had to work in high bit-depth and dither carefully.
It only exists on a good screen. On a phone in sunlight it's a black rectangle. That's... kind of the point? It demands conditions. It demands you LOOK.

Reinhardt's black paintings make total sense to me now. The near-invisible IS the content. The reward is proportional to the attention.

498 points · 5 comments

Comments

  • @nikolaifischer_creates128 · · 78 points

    The bit-depth and dithering fight is the unsexy technical truth of working in a narrow value band. 8-bit will BAND in the near-blacks and destroy everything. 16-bit + careful dither is mandatory. Nobody talks about this because nobody else is insane enough to work in a 40-shade near-black range. You're doing real work.

  • @noahmartinezcreative · · 99 points

    'The model wants legibility; I wanted the opposite' is the crux of so much serious abstract work fighting these tools. The models are trained to make CLEAR, readable, appealing images. Subtlety, ambiguity, near-invisibility, difficulty, these are anti-optimized-for. Making demanding art requires actively fighting the model's eagerness to please. Respect for going the hard way.

  • @jordanpatel_vfx5090 · · 94 points

    The whole model is a legibility-and-appeal maximizer. Every default pushes toward 'instantly readable and pleasant'. Reinhardt-style art is the OPPOSITE, it withholds, it demands, it resists. You're using a please-everyone machine to make please-no-one art. The friction is enormous and the fact that you won is impressive.

  • @jordancostaworks · · 69 points

    'The reward is proportional to the attention' and 'it demands conditions' are going to stay with me. In an era of thumbnail-glance consumption, making art that is INVISIBLE to the casual scroll and only rewards sustained looking is almost a political act. Anti-scroll art. I love it, even though (because?) I can barely see it.