What's the first thing you fix when a client says the spot feels a bit AI?

by @leomillercreative in c/cinematic-ad-studio · · Feedback Wanted

The dreaded 'it looks a little AI' note. When you get it, what's the first lever you pull? Vote then tell me what actually moved the needle.

  • The skin and faces (29 votes)
  • The motion, too smooth (39 votes)
  • Grade and color consistency (40 votes)
  • Product reflections (50 votes)
  • Sound design and foley (37 votes)
  • Micro-timing of the cuts (32 votes)

227 votes · poll closed

215 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @yukisingh_studio · · 63 points

    motion, every time. the #1 AI tell is that everything glides on rails, no weight, no settle, no micro-overshoot. i add weight to camera moves and a tiny settle to anything that stops, and the 'AI feeling' drops by half before i touch anything else.

  • @liammillerlab1512 · · 41 points

    the 'no settle' thing is huge, real objects and cameras OVERSHOOT and correct, AI motion eases perfectly to a stop like a dead CGI render. adding a 2-frame overshoot to every stop is the cheapest de-AI fix there is.

  • @oliviaparklab9217 · · 42 points

    for me it's always the grade, 'feels AI' usually means 'feels inconsistent' and once i shot-match everything to one reference the complaint evaporates. the client can't name it but mismatched color is what they're reacting to.

  • @jordansmith · · 29 points

    half the time 'it looks AI' just means 'the shots don't look like the same production,' which is a grade problem, not a gen problem. consistency reads as realness.

  • @taylorrobinson · · 33 points

    underrated answer: the audio. a silent too-clean mix makes even great footage feel synthetic. add room tone and real foley and the picture suddenly 'feels real' without changing a pixel. the ears sell the eyes.