First real attempt at a Sargent-style portrait. Be brutal, I can take it.

by @katyaitocreative in c/oil-painting · · Critique Welcome

Three days on this. Trying for that Sargent thing where the face is rendered and everything else dissolves into confident slashes.

Flux base, then a lot of hand-painting over the top in Procreate for the background strokes because the model would not stop finishing the collar. I know the left hand is cheating (hidden). I know.

What's bugging me and I can't name it: it reads 'almost' but there's a stiffness. Tell me what it is.

261 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @felixbrown_art · · 92 points

    Value structure is actually really strong, that's the hard part and you nailed it. The stiffness is edges + the collar is over-rendered relative to the face. Sargent would have said the collar in two strokes.

  • @akiraitocreative744 · · 99 points

    The stiffness is the edges again. Sargent's whole trick is that the background strokes are FASTER than the face. Yours are the same speed everywhere so nothing feels alla prima.

    Also the catchlight in both eyes is identical. Real eyes have slightly different speculars because they're not perfectly symmetrical to the light.

  • @leotanaka_creates · · 61 points

    Oh the matching catchlights thing is going to haunt me now, you're right.

  • @yukibrown · · 46 points

    it's good! but the forehead has that flux-skin sheen, slightly waxy. knock the highlight down like 15% and add the tiniest bit of broken color in the cheek.

  • @nikolaisantos_studio1143 · · 51 points

    brutal as requested: the earring is doing more acting than the eyes. but the paint quality is genuinely there, this isn't a filter.

  • @theopatelcreative · · 38 points

    the earring is doing more acting than the eyes KHSDFJK ok I'm repainting the eyes