Falling leaves in AI clips fall like confetti or like stones. Here's what got mine to drift like real leaves

by @jamesbrownmedia in c/cottagecore · · Meadow / Landscape

Late autumn is my favorite thing to film in cottagecore scenes and the hardest thing to get right. My first fifty attempts had two failure modes: leaves raining straight down like gravel, or swirling like confetti at a party.

What helped, roughly in order:

Name the leaf. "Oak leaves" and "maple leaves" fall differently, and the models seem to know it. "Leaves" alone gets you generic flakes.
Say how few. "A few leaves drifting down" beats "falling leaves". Fewer leaves get more motion detail each.
Give the wind a direction and a strength. "Light breeze from the left" made the biggest single difference.
Lock the camera. A static frame makes the leaf motion readable. Handheld + leaves = soup.
Ask for the flutter. Words like "tumbling", "side to side", "rocking" got me the pendulum swing real leaves do.

Still can't get leaves to land and stay landed. They tend to dissolve into the grass. Anyone solved that?

#autumn #leaves #physics #seasonal

59 points · 9 comments

Comments

  • @nikolaikimpro99 · · 6 points

    Real leaves also show the underside when they flip, which is a different color. If you say "pale undersides flashing as they turn" you get a lovely shimmer.

  • @jamesbrownmedia · · 1 point

    Just tried that on a birch scene. The flash is gorgeous.

  • @adriankimpro · · 6 points

    The landing thing is a known pain. I cut on the moment of landing and start the next shot with the leaf already on the ground. Hides it completely.

  • @jamesbrownmedia · · 0 points

    Cutting around it. Of course. Thank you.

  • @katyaitomedia512 · · 5 points

    Saving this. Number 3 is new to me. I never thought about giving the wind a direction.

  • @jamesbrownmedia · · 4 points

    It's the one I'd keep if I could only keep one.

  • @theo_plates · · 5 points

    Steam has the exact same problem. Too much and it's soup, too little and it's a sticker. "A thin thread of steam" is my version of your "a few leaves".

  • @jamesbrownmedia · · 1 point

    Quantity words seem to be the secret everywhere.

  • @bo_drone · · 3 points

    From above it's even harder. Leaves seen from a drone angle turn into noise. I gave up and only do leaves in close shots.