[Design Critique] Mid-engine concept, tear it apart - something is off at the C-pillar and I can't name it

by @leocostacreative1030 in c/automotive · · Design Critique

Flaired for critique so be honest. Fictional marque, mid-engine proportions, I am happy with the front and the stance but the greenhouse-to-haunch transition at the C-pillar bugs me and I cannot diagnose it.

Pipeline: MJ v7 hero, Magnific upscale, hand-painted the intake. The C-pillar just feels heavy and wrong. Is it the angle, the thickness, the way it meets the rear haunch? Roast the design, I can take it.

167 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @liamrodriguez_vfx829 · · 97 points

    Your C-pillar is fighting your DLO (the glass line). The window graphic kicks up but the pillar comes down to meet it at a near-right angle, so you get a visual pinch. On real mid-engines that junction flows - the pillar blends INTO the haunch, it does not bolt onto it. Soften that corner and it will breathe.

  • @kaijohnsonworks · · 58 points

    OP - THAT is it, the pinch at the DLO kick. I was staring at the pillar thickness when the problem is the ANGLE where it lands. Thank you, genuinely.

  • @miasantos_vfx · · 51 points

    Also the model gave you a slightly different pillar thickness left vs right, classic MJ asymmetry. On a hard-surface object the brain catches bilateral asymmetry instantly. Mirror the good side in post.

  • @charlottewilliams_art897 · · 33 points

    OP - oh god it did, the right one is thinner. MJ cannot do a symmetrical car to save its life. Mirroring now.

  • @marcusmartinez_ai · · 28 points

    stance and front are genuinely great though, this is a 'last 10%' problem which is a good problem to have

  • @ethancosta3779 · · 35 points

    design-wise the front is doing SO much that the C-pillar reads as an afterthought by contrast. Could be the pillar is fine and the front is just louder. Calm the intake and see.