Key animation: I hand-key the smears and extremes, let AI do the clean in-betweens. Is this cheating?

by @theowatanabe_creates in c/anime-studio · · Key Animation

Workflow confession. For a punch cut I drew the four frames that matter — anticipation, the smear frame, the impact extreme, the recoil — BY HAND, then used interpolation only for the clean held in-betweens between the slow parts. The result has actual sakuga snap because the KEYS carry the timing, and the AI just fills the boring middle.

When I tried the reverse — let the model generate everything and hand-fix — it was floaty garbage, because interpolation wants to make everything smooth and even, which is the exact opposite of good 2D timing. 2D lives on the HOLDS and the SNAPS, not the smooth bits.

So: is it cheating? I did the keys. The machine did the tweening. That's literally the genga/douga division a real studio runs. I think I'm fine? Convince me otherwise.

499 points · 9 comments

Comments

  • @emmasilva · · 98 points

    Not cheating, that's just... the job, correctly divided. Genga is the art, douga is labor. You did the art. Studios have had junior animators and now contractors do the tween for a century. Same thing.

  • @avakim_studio · · 71 points

    The crucial part you nailed: YOU own the timing because you own the keys. Floaty AI animation is always a timing failure, and timing lives in the key spacing, which the human sets. This is the right division.

  • @yunaperez_studio · · 57 points

    The 'interpolation wants everything smooth and even = anti-2D' insight is the whole ballgame. Western interpolation tools fight anime timing because anime is deliberately UNeven. Holds and snaps.

  • @diegoshah_art970 · · 37 points

    This is why straight frame interpolation on anime looks cursed. It smooths out the holds that give it punch. You have to protect the holds, which OP did by keying them.

  • @oscarpark_ai · · 29 points

    Counter-confession: I tried this and the AI in-betweens still had that subtle morph-wobble on the line even between two good keys. How are you keeping the lineart from boiling in the tween?

  • @mayamehta_digital · · 33 points

    Short tween spans (2-3 frames max between keys) and I run the whole cut through a line-stabilize pass after. Long interpolation spans are where the boil lives. Key more often than feels necessary.

  • @jamesmartinez_films9980 · · 38 points

    Welcome to how literally every production works. The only people calling this cheating have never cleaned a stack of douga at 3am for a flat rate.