Does a scan-based or img2img watercolor 'count' more than a pure text-prompt one?

by @elenapark5270 in c/watercolor ·

Sister question to the whole AI-art debate but specific to us: is a hybrid (real wash + AI) more legit than a from-scratch prompt? Or is legitimacy a dumb thing to chase? Vote, then argue.

  • Hybrid is more legit, real pigment involved (2 votes)
  • Doesn't matter, judge the final image (9 votes)
  • Pure prompt is its own valid thing (3 votes)
  • 'Legit' is a trap, make what you like (4 votes)

18 votes · poll closed

4 points · 5 comments

Comments

  • @sashapark_creates · · 63 points

    the real answer is that chasing 'legit' makes worse art than chasing 'good.' make the thing, stop auditing your own pipeline.

  • @lunawatanabe_films491 · · 92 points

    I lean hybrid-is-more-legit but I'll admit that's partly cope because I'm a traditional painter who feels better when my hand's involved. The final image is what the viewer gets though, and they can't tell.

  • @jasminehoffmann_studio993 · · 99 points

    the honesty of 'that's partly cope' earns the whole take. a lot of the 'more legit' feeling is about OUR relationship to the work, not the viewer's. and that's allowed to matter, just name it.

  • @jinsmith · · 74 points

    judge the final image. a stunning pure-prompt wash beats a mediocre hybrid. process is for US, result is for everyone else.