Rough cut of my sci-fi short, the ending lands flat and I genuinely can't see why anymore

by @zarasharma_studio62 in c/short-films · · Rough Cut

Six-minute piece. A courier on a dying colony has to decide whether to send the last transmission off-world or use the power to keep the greenhouse warm one more night. I love the setup. The ending feels like wet cardboard and I've watched it so many times I've gone face-blind to it.

My suspicion is the decision happens too fast, she just... does it, and we don't feel the cost. But every version where I slow it down feels indulgent. I'm stuck between 'too fast' and 'too long' with no 'just right' in sight.

Link to the unlisted cut in comments. Be brutal, I can take it, I need fresh eyes.

153 points · 10 comments

Comments

  • @ravisantos_studio · · 93 points

    Watched it. The problem isn't the pace of the decision, it's that we never SAW her want both things badly enough. You tell us the stakes, you don't make us feel her torn. Give her one earlier moment of tenderness with the greenhouse AND one with the radio. Then the choice cuts.

  • @felixsilvacreative7030 · · 52 points

    oh. oh no. you're completely right. she has a scene with the greenhouse but her relationship to the transmission is purely expository. the radio has no emotional scene. that's the hole.

  • @sakurasinghcreative · · 31 points

    the greenhouse glow as the only warm light in a cold film is gorgeous and you should lean into it even harder as a symbol. let the color do the emotional math.

  • @elenasanchez_studio96 · · 43 points

    whatever you do don't add a voiceover explaining her choice. I can feel you're tempted. don't.

  • @sashatanaka_creates200 · · 39 points

    ...I had written a voiceover. deleting the voiceover.

  • @benjaminperez591 · · 43 points

    disagree slightly with top comment, I think the ending is fine, the FIRST two minutes are the problem, you spend too long establishing the colony is dying and we get it in 20 seconds. the ending feels flat because we're already exhausted.

  • @liamsilvalab · · 38 points

    honestly could be both, a slow open makes a quick ending feel abrupt by contrast. tighten the front, the back might fix itself.